Author: Luthfi Dhofier

  • How Indonesia Lost the Battle Against the Coronavirus

    Indonesia coronavirus

    Image courtesy of Marketwatch

    Indonesian President Joko “Jokowi” Widodo’s response to the pandemic or lack thereof has sparked criticisms within and beyond Indonesia. The hashtag #lockdownordie is currently trending in Indonesia’s social media as Jokowi continues to resist experts’ advice to implement a nationwide lockdown. As of April 28, The Indonesian government has reported more than 9,100 cases and 765 deaths. But a recent Reuters review suggested that more than 2,200 people in Indonesia have died from the coronavirus. According to researchers at the University of Indonesia, there could be 15 million cases and 140,000 COVID-19 related deaths by the end of May. So how did Southeast Asia’s largest economy mishandle the pandemic? 

    At the heart of the problem is the government’s delayed response to the pandemic. WHO Governor-general Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus confirmed the first coronavirus case outside of mainland China on January 20. However, it took the government nearly three months since the announcement to finally take serious containment measures. 

    Despite early warnings from public health experts, the government continued to deny and downplay the risks. In February, the country’s health minister Terawan Agus Putranto dismissed a study by Harvard researchers that suggested Indonesia may have underreported the outbreak. Putranto also claimed that Indonesians are immune to the virus due to their prayers. Similarly, Jokowi had publicly endorsed a traditional Indonesian herb drink as an antidote to the virus. Meanwhile, the country’s vice president Amin Ma’ruf suggested that drinking wild-horse milk can ward-off the virus. These unscientific claims are misleading and dangerous as they can prevent the people from taking physical distancing or proper hygiene measures. 

    Jokowi was initially more interested in protecting the economy than protecting the people from the virus. When other countries started to impose travel restrictions, the government offered foreign and domestic travelers up to 30% discount on airline and hotel fees to save the country’s tourism industry. The government also allocated $5.2 million to pay social media influencers to promote Indonesia to foreign travelers. 

    Moreover, the government has received criticisms for its failure to conduct widespread testing. Despite the recent effort to increase the country’s COVID-19 testing capacity, Indonesia’s testing rate is still one of the lowest in the world, with 264 tests per one million people. Meanwhile, Malaysia and Thailand have testing rates of 4,063 and 2,043 per one million people, respectively. According to a senior member of Indonesia’s COVID-19 taskforce, nearly 20,000 suspected coronavirus carriers in the country have not been tested. 

    Lack of transparency is another key issue with Indonesia’s COVID-19 response. On April 5, the National Disaster Mitigation Agency (BNPB) spokesman Agus Wibowo said that the number of COVID-19 cases that the central government’s reported did not match the numbers reported by the provincial governments. It was later revealed that the government told Depok Mayor Mohamad Idris to hide information about the first two COVID-19 cases in the country. In addition to underreporting the number of cases, the government also did not provide the public with accurate information on infection hotspots. Jokowi eventually admitted that he withheld some information to prevent the public from panicking. But lack of transparency can intensify public confusion and the spread of misinformation. 

    Additionally, there has been poor coordination between the central government and the provincial governments, which created more confusion among the public and government officials. Jokowi’s inconsistent statements regarding the authority of provincial governments to impose local lockdowns have created conflicting policies at the central and provincial levels. 

    The government’s mishandling of the crisis is not only undermining the government’s credibility in fighting the outbreak, but also putting the people at serious health risks. The continued rise in COVID-19 infections is now putting enormous pressure on the country’s already fragile health care system. Indonesia only has 12 hospital beds and 4 doctors per thousand people. As a comparison, South Korea has 115 hospital beds and 24 doctors per thousand people. 

    With its limited financial and health care resources, Indonesia should respond to this current health crisis proactively and strategically. While there has been a series of setbacks, it is not too late for the government to fix its mistakes and turn the tide around. But the Indonesian government must show leadership and design policies based on scientific evidence. Additionally, the central government must ensure transparency and proper coordination with other levels of government. 

  • Why Canada Should Help Developing Countries Fighting to Flatten the Curve

    Originally published on the Hamilton Spectator

    nigeria_bombers_women_4

    The spread of COVID-19 in developing countries will have catastrophic global consequences. Ottawa’s current $50-million commitment to help developing countries deal with the pandemic is a step in the right direction. However, Canada must do more to assist developing countries to contain the spread of the virus.

    To date, advanced economies such as the United States, Italy and France have been suffering the most from the virus. In Canada, more than 11,000 cases have been reported along with 153 deaths. However, the next wave of the outbreak is expected to hit developing countries and the impact will likely devastate their fragile economies and weak health care systems.

    The International Monetary Fund (IMF) has stated its commitment to mobilize $1 trillion to help countries that are struggling with the economic impact of the coronavirus. The IMF and the World Bank are also working together on emergency programs to help member countries, particularly developing countries and emerging markets.

    However, the current aid that has been made available for developing countries will not be sufficient. Since the outbreak began, more than $83 billion worth of capital had fled the emerging markets. According to the IMF chief Kristalina Georgieva, developing countries need at least $2.5 trillion in financial assistance to cope with the pandemic. The United Nations Secretary-General Antonio Guterres has also asked world leaders to provide developing countries with $2 trillion to help them fight the outbreak.

    Unlike advanced economies such as Canada, developing countries do not have the wherewithal to contain the virus. Even without the outbreak, many low-income countries relied on foreign aid to survive. Guterres argued that “there are dramatic humanitarian needs for these people even without this pandemic. But now, with COVID-19, we need to do everything possible to prevent the disease from coming to these areas.”

    In sub-Saharan Africa, there is only about one doctor per 5,000 people, compared to one for every 300 in Europe. The region is also lacking basic medical tools such as ventilators, beds, and masks. In Mali, for example, there is only roughly one ventilator per one-million people.

    Moreover, 41 percent of sub-Saharan Africa’s population is living in poverty. According to the Brookings Institute, the pandemic could reduce sub-Saharan Africa’s GDP by 2.1 percent. In a region where sustained economic growth is desperately needed to lift people out of abject poverty, the economic impact of the coronavirus will create serious economic and social problems.

    The outbreak and its economic impact can also fuel political violence in the region. In 2019, political violence in sub-Saharan Africa killed over 2,000 people and displaced thousands more. In places like Kenya and South Africa, COVID-19 containment measures have already turned violent as police used excessive force to enforce lockdowns and curfews.

    In the Middle East where some countries are still fighting wars, COVID-19 will escalate sectarian tensions and regional instability. For example, officials in Bahrain have accused Iran of “biological aggression.” The region’s youth unemployment rate is currently one of the highest in the world at 26.1 percent. Measures to contain the virus will likely increase this number and lead to civil unrest.

    Many other countries in Asia and Latin America are also facing similar risks.

    To date, the government of Canada has only earmarked $50 million to help poor countries deal with coronavirus. Some even suggested that now is not that time for Canada to use its resources to help people in other countries. In his tweet, Conservative leadership candidate Erin O-Toole said: “Foreign aid can wait. Right now, the Trudeau government should prioritize Canadians.”

    But ensuring a stable international order is in Canada’s national interests. A major outbreak in developing countries can lead to global security issues such as terrorism, state violence, and refugee crises. All these problems will be detrimental to Canada’s national security.

    Currently, Canada only spends about 0.28 percent of its GDP on international development assistance (ODA). Meanwhile, other OECD countries such as Norway and Ireland spend at least 0.7 percent of their GDPs on ODA. Norway has also pledged $30 million to help developing countries fight the coronavirus, despite having a GDP of a mere $402 billion. With a GDP of more than $1.6 trillion, Canada should spend at least $150 million.

    The current pandemic requires Canada to step up and demonstrate its global leadership. Providing other countries with the financial resources to contain the spread of the virus will help protect Canadians now and in the future.

    Luthfi Dhofier is a policy analyst based in Vancouver. He recently graduated from UBC’s Master of Public Policy and Global Affairs program.

  • Poor Access to Clean Water Will Make Developing Countries Vulnerable to Coronavirus

    World Water Day was recently celebrated to highlight the importance of clean water. Almost all human activities require water, including food production, energy generation, and health provision. Globally, 800 million people, mostly in developing countries, do not have access to clean water. Lack of clean water contributes to a myriad of health problems such as diarrhea cholera, and dysentery. Every year, 3.4 million people, mostly children, die from water-related diseases. Water is also crucial in the current fight against COVID-19, as frequent handwashing can significantly reduce the spread of the virus. This means those 800 million people who have no access to clean water are highly vulnerable to the illness. The current COVID-19 pandemic is a sobering reminder that clean water is a critical requirement for human health.

    At the time of this writing, the virus has infected more than 330,000 people in 173 countries and killed 14,000. On March 11, the World Health Organization declared COVID-19 a global pandemic. With the exception of a few countries such as Taiwan and South Korea, governments around the world are struggling to contain the spread of the virus. Italy now has more deaths than China, while the United States and other European countries continue to see spikes in cases and deaths.

    In many developing countries, containing the spread of COVID-19 will be extremely challenging as they are already dealing with ongoing economic issues and weak healthcare systems.

    handwashing.jpg

    COVID-19 went undetected in many developing countries for a few months. Pakistan confirmed its first case as late as February 26, while Indonesia’s first case was only reported in early March. Yet, Southeast Asia now has more than 3,200 cases and in Africa, more than 1,100 cases have been confirmed. The numbers will only continue to rise. Governments in Egypt, Peru, and Nigeria have all imposed travel restrictions and banned public gatherings in their efforts to contain the virus.

    However, preventing the spread of COVID-19 also requires proper hygiene, which includes frequent handwashing for 20 seconds. While this may seem like a simple hygiene practice, there are millions of people who cannot wash their hands as they do not have access to clean water.

    According to UNICEF, forty percent of people around the world do not have access to handwashing facilities and soap in their homes. Fifty percent of schools in developing countries do not have handwashing facilities.

    In Africa, 258 million people do not have access to handwashing facilities. Many people who live in Africa and Asia must walk for more than 10 kilometers to obtain water from distant sources and the water is often contaminated with various harmful pathogens. Moreover, women mostly bear the responsibility to collect water, which deprives them of education and employment and exposes them to violence. For these people, frequent handwashing does not make too much sense as they already lack water for drinking purposes.

    Healthcare facilities in developing countries lack access to clean water, increasing healthcare workers’ exposure to the virus as they are not able to wash their hands as frequently as they should. A study by WHO found that 1 in 5 healthcare facilities around the world does not have adequate basic water services. This situation will likely exacerbate the spread of COVID-19 in these countries.

    The current COVID-19 pandemic shows that diseases can easily move from one country to another and become a global crisis. In this interconnected world, the lack of universal access to clean water can exacerbate global health risks. Therefore, improving global access to clean water must be a concerted effort by all countries.

    The United Nations Sustainable Development Goal (SDG) 6 provides a framework to ensure sustainable management of water and sanitation for all. However, the world is not on track to meet this goal and the amount of funding that goes into this effort must significantly increase. Rich countries can do more to help developing countries improve their water infrastructures and management.

  • Climate change impacts water security in Egypt, India, Indonesia and Australia

    Originally posted on the Vancouver Sun

    new-zealand-economy.jpg

    “The bravest are surely those who have the clearest vision of what is before them, glory and danger alike, and yet notwithstanding go out to meet it.” — Pericles

    Every year on March 22, World Water Day raises global awareness about the importance of freshwater. The theme for this year’s World Water Day is “water and climate change.”

    Globally, 98 per cent of water is salt and two per cent is fresh. In 2020, 800 million global citizens have no clean water source in their home, village or community. That number is expected to reach two billion by 2050. Four countries are particularly struck by water insecurity and climate change: Egypt, India, Indonesia, and Australia.

    Egypt, with a population of 81 million, relies on the revered Nile River as its water source. The harsh climate change impacts confronting Egypt include drought, sea-level rise, extreme temperature, sandstorms, heatwaves, and desertification. Only four per cent of the landmass of the country is inhabited and the population is projected to double by 2100. The country receives an average annual rainfall of 80 mm and only six per cent of the land is arable, with the Nile supplying 97 per cent of the nation’s water.

    According to one study: “Egypt is facing an annual water deficit of seven billion cubic meters. By the year 2020, the country will be consuming 20 per cent more water than it has and the United Nations is already warning that Egypt could face extreme water scarcity by 2025.” Moreover, plans by Ethiopia, an upriver country, to dam the Nile for massive hydroelectric projects will negatively impact Egyptian water security. The project has polarized relations between the two states.

    India is the most populous country in the world and projected to have 1.6 billion citizens by 2050. The population is hit by massive climate change assaults from drought, floods, sea-level rise, water insecurity, extreme heat, and extreme weather. Currently, India ranks 129th on the Human Development Index with approximately 224 million citizens living below the international poverty line of US$1.90 per day. Water tables have dramatically fallen from 4,500 in 1950 to 1,500 meters in 2017.

    As noted in a recent analysis, “700 million out of over 1 billion population living in rural areas directly depends on climate-sensitive sectors, (agriculture, forests, and fisheries) and natural resources (such as water, biodiversity, mangroves, coastal zones, grasslands) for their subsistence and livelihoods. Heatwaves, floods (land and coastal), and droughts occur commonly. Millions of Indian citizens in New Delhi, Chennai, Mumbai, and other cities and towns are struggling with chronic water shortages that imperil health and development.

    Additionally, 26 per cent of the Indian labour force depends upon agriculture, which is struggling with water shortages that restrict proper irrigation.

    In Indonesia, climate change has increased the frequency of both floods and droughts. Currently, 27 million people (10 per cent of the population) in Indonesia do not have access to clean drinking water. Last year, Indonesia experienced the worst droughts since 2015, with 11 provinces going without rain for more than seven months.

    Other parts of the country have experienced torrential rain. According to the country’s Meteorology, Climatology, and Geophysics Agency, climate change was the main driver of the heavy rain that caused floods in Jakarta over the past few months, killing more than 60 people and displacing 175,000. Increased floods exacerbate pollution and diseases, putting millions of people at risk.

    Climate change also threatens water security in rich countries. Most recently, Australia experienced what may be the worst droughts in 400 years. In its drought strategy report that was published last year, the Australian government suggests climate change will continue to increase the severity and frequency of droughts in some parts of Australia and they may become more “marginal and unproductive.”

    Climate change will also reduce water availability in Australian cities. One study found that Melbourne, Australia’s second-largest city, will experience water shortages if the global temperature rise reaches 2 degrees C. To mitigate this risk, the Australian government must significantly increase its desalination capacity. However, desalination will come with serious economic and environmental costs.

    The water crises in Egypt, India, Indonesia, and Australia are only a few examples of how climate change is threatening water security for millions of people around the world.

    Dr. Ross Michael Pink is a political science professor at Kwantlen Polytechnic University in Surrey. He is the author of Water Rights in Southeast Asia and The Climate Change Crisis: Solutions and Adaption for a Planet in Peril; Luthfi Dhofier is a policy analyst in Vancouver, BC. He holds a Master of Public Policy and Global Affairs from UBC. The pair co-founded Global Water Rights in 2013 to promote water rights and security.

  • Why Indonesia Needs More Than Just A Tougher Anti Terror Law

    densus 88

    In the wake of terror attacks that rocked the city of Surabaya in May 2018, Indonesia’s parliament has unanimously passed an amendment to its antiterrorism law. Initially proposed in 2016, the law was put on hold after the parliament members could not agree on what constitutes terrorism. President Joko Widodo (Jokowi) had threatened to issue a government in lieu of law (perrpu) if the parliament could not pass the law by June. The new law provides the law enforcers with greater powers to carry out their duties.

    Rights groups have argued that the new law would undermine human rights in the country. In an open letter to Indonesia’s House of Representative, Amnesty International expresses its concerns about the new antiterrorism law. Indonesia’s Minister of Law and Human Rights Yasona Laoly maintains that the new law is in line with human rights standards. Antiterrorism laws and policies have always been a contentious subject, particularly with respect to human rights.

    While the new antiterrorism law serves as an essential legal foundation to improve the law enforcers’ capacity in combating terrorism, Indonesia must seriously improve its “soft power” measures to counter the spread of hardline ideologies that often translate to terror attacks.

    The Rise of Terror Attacks and Religious Incidents in Indonesia

     The deadliest terrorist incident in Indonesia occurred in 2002 when a Jihadist detonated a bomb at a nightclub in Bali, killing at least 200 people and injuring 200 more. Many of those who were killed in the explosion were foreigners, putting Indonesia in an international spotlight. Shortly thereafter, terrorism became the main security concern for Indonesia’s government.

    After a decade of considerable success in counterterrorism measures, Indonesia saw a resurgence of terror attacks. Many of these attacks were inspired by ISIS. Since 2013, there have been at least 930 Indonesians who have travelled to Syria to join ISIS, including women and children. According to Moeldoko, the Chief of Staff of the Presidency, there are currently 590 Indonesian Jihadists in Syria, while 86 of them have returned home.

    The recent attacks on churches in Surabaya that killed 26 people and injured at least 50 were also ISIS-affiliated. The Surabaya attacks marked a shift in the nature of terrorism in Indonesia. In the past, the perpetrators had all been men; whilst in Surabaya, women and children were involved in the attacks. This has never been seen before. What the Surabaya attacks indicate is that hardline ideologies have become appealing to not only adult men but also women and children.

    Indonesia has been praised for its “moderate” version of Islam, where Muslims embrace elements of Buddhism, Hinduism, and animism while living relatively peacefully with other religious groups. However, Indonesia’s moderate Islam has dwindled in recent years. A study by The Wahid Institute found that 60 percent of high students in Indonesia would join violent jihadist movements. The PEW Research also found that 72 percent of Indonesians are in favor of making sharia the law of the land.

    These developments indicate that Indonesia has gradually become a fertile ground for hardline ideologies that often translate into violent acts.

    Tougher Anti Terrorism Law

     There are several key aspects of the new law that will improve antiterrorism measures in Indonesia.

    First, the new law expands Indonesia’s definition of terrorism. Under the new law, terrorism constitutes “the use of violence or threats to inflict a widespread terror and fear, that could lead to considerable loss of lives and/or destruction of strategic vital objects, environment, and public/international properties with political/ideological motives.”

    Second, the new law extends the detention period from seven to fourteen days before a person is identified as a terrorist suspect, and extends the pre-trial detention period from six months to nine months, without the court’s approval.

    Third, the new law grants the Indonesian military (TNI) a direct involvement in antiterrorism activities. However, TNI may only participate in antiterrorism activities when it is requested by the police and approved by the president.

    In light of concerns over human rights violations, Indonesia’s lawmakers incorporated several articles that would govern the adherence to human rights principles. For example, article 25 subparagraphs 7 and 8 stipulate that the detention of suspected terrorists must be carried out while upholding human rights principles and any official who violates these standards would be prosecuted according to law.

    Will The Law Be Enough To Prevent Future Attacks?

    Tougher antiterrorism legislation is only one facet of a broader counterterrorism strategy. The government of Indonesia must also intensify its de-radicalization measures. During a meeting at the State Palace, Jokowi has indicated his commitment to balancing “hard power” and “soft power” approaches, without providing further details on what this soft power entails.

    However, to mitigate the spread of radical ideologies, Indonesia must first ensure that its deradicalization programs targets not only men who have been engaged with militant groups, but also their families and close affiliates. As the Surabaya attacks demonstrated, women, children, affiliates of those former jihadists are also prone to committing terror attacks.

    In addition to educating and integrating former jihadists and their affiliates, the government must address the spread of radical ideologies in Indonesia’s educational institutions, particularly in private Islamic schools.

    Finally, the government must continue to work with moderate Islamic groups such as the Nahdlatul Ulama (NU) and Muhammadiyah to promote and re-invigorate “moderate” Islam, the Islam that had been thriving in the archipelago for centuries.

     

     

     

     

  • Reflection on Fukuyama: the Unravelling of the Liberal World Order and the Rise of Populism

    Fukuyama francis.jpgOn January 24, 2018, Francis Fukuyama, a world-renowned political scientist, spoke to some few hundred students, faculty and public audience at the University of British Columbia (UBC). The talk was part of the Liu Institute’s Phil Lind Initiative. I had the opportunity to attend the event and here are highlights from the event.

    What is populism?

    In his remarks, Fukuyama suggests that the Liberal World Order that was spearheaded by the United States after the Second World War has been challenged by the rise of populism, particularly in the western world. Fukuyama provides three different characteristics of populism:

    1. Economic nationalism: Populist movements are typically anti-trade and advocate a retreat from the global economic system.
    2. Appeals to only certain groups: Populism is not an inclusive movement. It appeals only to certain segments of society. For example, Donald Trump’s followers are predominantly white Americans in rural areas.
    3. Weakening democratic institutions: Populist leaders hinges on personality and demagoguery. As such, democratic institutions such as the judicial and legislative branches that check the executive’s authority would be considered as a liability to his/her authority.

    Why populism?

    According to Fukuyama, the rise of populism can be attributed to three problems: First, the liberal economic model has not benefited the mainstream population. As a result of which, the gap between the rich and the rest has grown larger than ever. Political gridlock throughout liberal democracies has also contributed to the rise of populism. Fukuyama defined this as ‘vetoism’, where the political elites are unable to deliver results. One example of ‘vetoism’ is the government shutdowns that occur frequently in the United States. The last problem that leads to populism is the cultural decline, where many people believe they have become invisible to the coastal or bi-coastal elites.

    Rethinking the Liberal Democratic Order

    Fukuyama’s solution to the ‘liberal democratic order’ is to have an integrated national identity that is liberal, or in other words, loyal to the liberal principle.

    There were some serious contradictions in Fukuyama’s robust defense of the liberal order. He argued that despite rising wealth inequality, global economic growth has lifted hundreds of millions of people out of poverty. At the same time, he criticized China’s economic model, which he believes focuses too much on growth. Fukuyama ignored the fact that it was in China that we saw over 500 millions people lifted out of abject poverty.

    As many other neo-liberal thinkers, Fukuyama’s solution to the current problem is to ‘restore’ the liberal order, without reflecting the core problems that exist in that order. Maybe instead of restoring the liberal order, it’s time to reform the order itself. For decades, the liberal order as we know it has brought extreme wealth inequality, environmental degradation, and authoritarianism

    So how can we reform our democratic institutions?

    1. Redefining economic development:

    The unchecked and uncompromising pursuit of excessive capital accumulation, that is at the heart of the liberal order, is the root cause of the current ‘democratic recession.’ It is time for us to reform our economic system by incorporating environmental sustainability and equity in our growth model

    1. Strengthening our democratic institution

    We need to make sure that our democratic process is inclusive. We know that the American political stage is reserved for the elites. Almost all U.S Presidents came from an elite background, while in China, all Presidents came from a humble background. As it stands now, the political system in America and many other western countries are neither democratic nor liberal, as it is reserved for the few elites. Keeping money out of the electoral process while increasing transparency would help us strengthen our democratic institutions.

    As I am writing this piece, our ‘global elites’ are meeting in Davos for the annual World Economic Forum summit, discussing inequality while staying at the Alpine resort, where a room costs $500 per night. Tickets to the event (for those without special invitation) costs C$ 85,000 each. It is no wonder that many of us are feeling restless and losing faith in the liberal democratic order.

  • A Brief Look at Russia’s Economic Profile

    EMEA-MoscowSince the collapse of the Soviet Union in 1991, the Russian Federation has implemented an array of economic reforms that transformed the country from a centrally planned economy to a market-based economy. With a population of over 144 million and a GDP per-capita of $24,026, Russia is a significant actor in the global economy (World Bank, 2017). As a resource-rich country, Russia is one of the world’s largest exporters of oil and gas and a top producer of metals such as steel and aluminum (CIA World Factbook, 2017).

    However, heavy reliance on commodity exposes Russia’s economy to the boom and bust cycles of the commodity price, such as the fall of global oil price in 2014. Geopolitics also substantially affects Russia’s economic performance. For example, Russia’s military intervention in Ukraine led to an economic sanction imposed by the United States (Freedom House, 2017). Political and economic reforms spearheaded in the 1990s stalled in recent years (CIA World Factbook, 2017). As a result, several key economic problems remain: high concentration of wealth in the hands of government officials, rampant corruption, and continuous government meddling in the private sector (CIA World Factbook, 2017).

    oil.jpg

    However, the recovering global economy, firming oil price, and growing macroeconomic stability have all led to an uptick in Russia’s economy (World Bank). Thus, the Russian government signaled its plan for fiscal consolidation that would manage the impact of external factors on the budget and real exchange rate (World Bank). It is apparent that there is a substantial level of uncertainties in the Russian economy and we have yet to see Moscow to move gradually from its overreliance on oil, weed out corruption, and improve its global diplomacy.

  • The Underwhelming Canada-Indonesia Relationship

    JT JOKO

    (Prime Minister Justin Trudeau met today with Indonesian President Joko Widodo on the margins of the G20 Summit in Turkey – source: Prime Minister’s Office of Canada archive)

    Prime Minister Justin Trudeau’s visit to China is an important foreign policy move, but there is one country in the Asia Pacific that Canada should not ignore.

    The relationship between Canada and Indonesia traces back to 1948 when Canada became one of the first countries to recognize Indonesia’s independence. Shortly thereafter, the formal bilateral relationship between the two countries was established. Unfortunately, Canada has yet to be successful with capitalizing on the economic opportunities from the relationship. A 2016 report by the Centre for International Governance Cooperation (CIGC) found that there is a serious deficit in mutual awareness between Canadians and Indonesians. Indonesia is currently the largest country in Southeast Asia in terms of economy, population and geography. It is a diverse nation whereby 50% of its 250-million population is under the age of thirty. According to the McKinsey Global Institute (2012), Indonesia is poised to be the seventh largest economy by 2030. As Canada looks to boost its global footprint, it needs to seriously improve its bilateral relationship with Indonesia. A strong Canada-Indonesia relationship will make Canada a stronger player in the Asia Pacific.

    Canada and Indonesia share an array of similarities that could serve as a foundation for a stronger, long-term bilateral relationship. First, the two countries have a democratic, multiparty political system. As a matter of fact, Indonesia is considered to be the only country in Southeast Asia with a Western-style democratic system. Second, the two countries are largely multicultural. There are currently more than 200 ethnic groups in Indonesia, speaking over 700 languages. Third, both countries are members of major international blocs such as the G20 and APEC.

    There are four key areas where Canada can improve its bilateral relationship with Indonesia. First, Canada must enhance its diplomatic relationship with Indonesia by officially upgrading the relationship to a tier-one relationship by 2020. Canada needs to place Indonesia as Canada’s main strategic partner in Southeast Asia. Second, Canada needs to upgrade its security relationship with Indonesia by initiating high-level military cooperation. Third, Canada must reinvigorate its economic relationship with Indonesia. Trade between the two countries currently stands at a mere $3.5 billion while the two countries’ combined GDP is close to $3 trillion. Therefore, total trade can definitely be improved. Fourth, Canada must increase educational assistance to Indonesia. Canada’s excellent post-secondary education system is undoubtedly enticing to Indonesia’s large young population. By promoting Canada’s education system in Indonesia, and awarding more scholarships to Indonesian students, the two countries could have a stronger cultural, people-to-people relationship. This will also accrue to other areas such as enhanced economic cooperation, governance, and security.

    Canada’s most recent initiative with regard to its relationship with Indonesia was its $14.25 injection to infrastructure development in Indonesia. However, there has yet to be a substantial effort from senior-level Canadian bureaucrats in demonstrating Canada’s commitment to Indonesia. To be fair, the Indonesian government has not been showing its commitment to Canada either. Canada could potentially be a strong North American ally for Indonesia considering the recent United States’ withdrawal from the global diplomacy under the Trump administration. The last time an Indonesian President officially visited Canada was back in 1956 when Sukarno visited Prime Minister Louis St. Laurent in Ottawa. This illustrates how distant the two countries are from the bilateral relationship standpoint. Although it takes ‘two to tango,’ as a developed country that is in more of a position for global outreach, it is time for Canada to take the first step in strengthening its bilateral relationship with this large yet unknown Southeast Asian nation.

  • Understanding China’s Foreign Aid

    China is poised to become the world’s largest economy and foreign aid donor. As the Trump administration is planning to cut back its foreign aid budget, China is expanding its global development footprint. As a recipient of foreign aid just a few decades ago, China’s growing presence in other countries is astonishing. The latest report on  China’s foreign aid by AidData is so far the most comprehensive study on China’s foreign aid initiatives. The study found that between 2000 and 2014, China has spent around $354.3 billion in global development initiatives, while the United States spent $394.6 billion.

    What does AidData mean for our understanding of Chinese foreign aid?

    First, it gives us more accurate insights on the structure and the recipients of China’s foreign aid initiatives. Prior to the publication of this study, we did not have  a clear understanding of China’s global footprint as China has kept this information confidential. Second, it debunks some of the misconceptions of China’s foreign aid.Various studies have reported that China’s foreign aid is not helping the recipient countries’ economic growth and it is impairing western aid. However, AidData’s findings indicate that none of these findings are true.  Using the Tracking Underreported Financial Flows (TUFF) methodology, AidData collected the total financial flows from China to recipient countries.

    Below is a snapshot of AidData’s study on China’s Foreign Aid

    Screen Shot 2017-10-13 at 9.02.17 PM.png

    (Source: AidData)

    How does Chinese foreign aid work?

    The study found that China allocates its foreign aid in three different methods. The first is the Official Development Assistance (ODA). This is a traditional state-to-state assistance where the recipient countries do not have the obligation to pay back their donors. This type of aid, according to AidData, is the most effective type of aid as they correlate with the recipient countries’ economic growth. However, China’s ODA is only less than a quarter of its total foreign assistance. In comparison, the United States’ foreign aid is primarily (93%) in the form of ODA.

    The second type of aid is Other Official Flows (OOF) or sets of commercial lending that needs to be paid back by the recipient countries. This type of aid, according to AidData, is purely based on Chinese commercial interests in the recipient countries. The third type of aid is Vague Official Finance (VOF), which is simply financial assistance that does not fall into ODA and OOF classifications due to lack of information. According to the study, the vast majority of China’s money goes to infrastructure projects such as energy generation and transportation.

    Screen Shot 2017-10-13 at 9.34.14 PM.png

    (source: AidData)

     Where does Chinese money go?

    Contrary to popular belief,  the biggest recipient of China’s aid has not been an African or Asian country. Between 2000 and 2014, the main recipient of China’s foreign aid has been Russia at $36.6 billion, followed by Pakistan at $24.3 billion and Angola at $16.6 billion. The study also found that North Korea has only received a mere $210 million in the last 14 years.

    Screen Shot 2017-10-13 at 10.07.14 PM.png

    (source: AidData)

    Points taken from the study

    This study tells us several things. First, it shows that China’s ODA actually contributes to the recipient countries’ economic growth. Second, it shows that Chinese aid and western aid can go hand in hand as the former does not impair the latter. Lastly, the study suggests that China has the capacity to be a constructive player in the global development.

     References 

    AidData. 2017. Global Chinese Official Finance Dataset, Version 1.0. Retrieved from http://aiddata.org/data/chinese-global-official-finance-dataset

    https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/worldviews/wp/2017/10/11/china-treats-its-foreign-aid-like-a-state-secret-new-research-aims-to-reveal-it/?utm_term=.90474e83ee2d

    http://foreignpolicy.com/2017/10/11/russia-is-the-biggest-recipient-of-chinese-foreign-aid-north-korea/

    http://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-china-41564841

    https://www.wsj.com/articles/when-it-comes-to-foreign-aid-chinas-taking-care-of-business-1507694463

  • ASEAN and the Myanmar Conundrum

    What is the Rohingya Crisis?

    The ongoing violence that is taking place in Myanmar has turned into the world’s fastest-developing refugee crisis. More than 420,000 Rohingya Muslims have fled to Bangladesh in the last three weeks, 240,000 of them are children. In his public statement, one UN official called this crisis “ethnic cleansing.” The situation has tarnished Aung San Suu Kyi’s status as a human right champion and posed serious security concerns on Myanmar’s neighboring countries.

    Background

    The violent oppression of Rohingyas by Myanmar’s security forces can be traced back to the passing of Myanmar’s Union Citizenship Act in 1948, of which the Rohingyas were not given the citizenship status. Deprived from their basic citizenship rights, the Rohingyas have been victims of various acts of oppressions for many decades.

    The recent crisis started in October 2016, after nine Myanmar police officers were killed. Shortly thereafter, the government started a crackdown against Rohingya Muslims, resulting in various human rights abuses. The Association of South East Asian Nations (ASEAN), has been reluctant to act on the issue, damaging its status as the region’s main intergovernmental organization.

    Implications in the Region

    Several ASEAN countries have experienced the impact of the violence, with hundreds of thousands of refugees fleeing Myanmar. As Myanmar’s closest neighbor, Bangladesh is currently hosting the majority of these refugees and providing them with food, medicine and water. As we have learned from the Syrian crisis, the influx of refugees on hosting countries can have serious political, social, and economical implications.

    In recent years, various militant groups such as the Islamic Defender Front (FPI), the Jemaah Islamiyah (JI), and the Abu Sayyaf Group (ASF) in the Philippines have been able to establish solid footholds in South East Asia. The crisis in Myanmar has provided these groups with momentum to gain followers. Several mass protests have taken place in Indonesia, calling the Indonesian government to take measures to end the crisis in Myanmar. Last week, the FPI leadership called upon the Indonesian Muslims to wage “Jihad” in Myanmar.

    ASEAN’s Failure

    Politicians in Indonesia and Malaysia have condemned the violence and criticized ASEAN for its unwillingness to take action. One Indonesian MP has publicly stated that the Rohingya crisis demonstrates the failure of ASEAN experiment. After ASEAN’s failure to explicitly mention the Rohingya community as the main victim of the crisis, the Foreign Minister of Malaysia said that ASEAN’s statement on the crisis was a “misrepresentation of the reality of the situation,” and that Malaysia “would like to disassociate itself” from the statement.

    Kishore Mahbubani, Dean of the Lee Kuan Yew School of Public Policy recently published The ASEAN Miracle, where he argued that the world should learn from ASEAN on how to manage regional conflicts. ASEAN, he said, is the world’s most effective regional cooperation that puts consultations and consensus over sanctions and military actions, hence allowed South East Asia to be the world’s most peaceful region. However, many would wonder if there is truth behind his argument, as ASEAN has been ineffective in mitigating the crisis in Myanmar.

    The Way Forward

    Whether through ASEAN or not, it is clear that countries such as Indonesia and Malaysia need to be more involved in the conflict. There are several ways where these two countries can be constructive partners in the region. First, they need to increase the humanitarian aid to ensure that those who are affected by the crisis have adequate access to food, water and medicine. Second, they need to manage relationships between religious groups in their respective countries. Measures like dialogue between religious leaders and empowering moderate Muslims can be effective tools to achieve this. Third, they should assist Bangladesh in taking Rohingya refugees. Fourth, they need to put more pressure on ASEAN to address this issue collectively.

    ASEAN leaders need to wake up and realize that the crisis in Myanmar is not just an issue for Myanmar. It is a humanitarian issue that will affect the region and the world.