Tag: COVID-19

  • COVID-19: What Indonesia Can Learn From South Korea and Taiwan

    Originally published on Fair Observer

    For Indonesia, a total lockdown could have cataclysmic social and economic consequences. A different approach is needed.

    As the coronavirus spreads fast in Indonesia, experts believe that the country will become Asia’s new epicenter. President Joko “Jokowi” Widodo has been criticized for not implementing a nationwide lockdown.

    Yet such measures would not be a silver bullet to contain COVID-19, the disease caused by the novel coronavirus. Other countries such as South Korea and Taiwan have flattened the curve while keeping businesses and schools open. Indonesia has a lot to learn from these two countries on how to contain the virus without locking down the whole country.

    At the time of publishing, there have been over 12,000 confirmed cases of COVID-19 in Indonesia and 870 deaths. Given the lack of widespread testing in a country with a population of 267 million, it is likely that the actual number of cases is far higher than this. According to a study by the University of Indonesia, there could be 1.5 million people infected and 140,000 deaths by the end of May. 

    Indonesia’s Response to COVID-19

    The Indonesian government’s response to the crisis has been lackluster. At the beginning of the outbreak, Health Minister Terawan Agus Putranto famously said that Indonesians are immune to COVID-19 due to their prayers. He also publicly dismissed a report by Harvard researchers that projected infection rates in Indonesia. Similarly, Jokowi deliberately misinformed the public early on to prevent them from panicking.

    In the past several weeks, the government has increased its containment measures. Jokowi has established a COVID-19 task force and declared a national emergency. However, experts believe that Indonesia is still behind the curve.

    Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus, the director-general of the World Health Organization, has also urged Jokowi to scale up Indonesia’s COVID-19 response mechanisms. Others believe that the country must implement a nationwide lockdown instead of only a partial one. But Jokowi maintains that this is off the table as he believes there are economic, social, political and security aspects that must be considered. 

    Indeed, in countries with limited resources like Indonesia, a total lockdown could have devastating consequences such as mass poverty and social unrest. In some parts of Africa, lockdowns have contributed to a rise in violence and hunger.

    Alternatively, Indonesia can learn from South Korea and Taiwan as these two countries have successfully contained the coronavirus without implementing a nationwide lockdown. To date, both countries have gradually removed some of the social distancing measures as the number of new infections goes down. 

    In South Korea, the infection rate has decreased from more than 900 cases a day to just under 10 cases per day. French President Emmanuel Macron and Swedish Prime Minister Stefan Lofven have both contacted South Korea’s president, Moon Jae In, to seek advice on how to combat the virus. 

    Similarly, despite its close proximity to China (130 kilometers away), Taiwan has effectively managed the outbreak without drastic restrictions. In 2019, 2.71 million Chinese visitors traveled to Taiwan and, as of January, there were dozens of flights between Wuhan — the Chinese city where COVID-19 first emerged — and Taipei every week. Yet at the time of publishing, Taiwan only has 438 confirmed cases of COVID-19. 

    Learning From South Korea and Taiwan

    There are some key principles that Indonesia can emulate from South Korea and Taiwan’s response to the coronavirus pandemic.

    First, Indonesia must commit to open and transparent communication. Officials in both South Korea and Taiwan hold daily media briefings to provide the public with timely, accurate and simple updates about the outbreak. Open and transparent communication can increase public engagement, prevent misinformation and stop people from panicking. As South Korea’s Vice Health Minister Kim Gang-Lip suggested, “public participation must be secured through openness and transparency.” 

    Second, Indonesia should incorporate advanced technology into its containment efforts. In South Korea, the government deployed a smartphone app to track the movements of those who have been ordered to self-quarantine. Additionally, travelers from China are required to download a self-diagnosis app to report their health conditions to the government.

    In Taiwan, the government uses an “electronic fence” that utilizes mobile phone signals to track people who are ordered to self-isolate. To ensure compliance, officials receive an alert when cellphones are turned off for more than 15 minutes. The government also integrated databases owned by the National Health Insurance Administration, National Immigration Agency and the Customs Administration to monitor people’s travel and medical history. As more than 70% of Indonesians have access to the internet through mobile phones, the use of advanced technology can significantly improve the government’s containment measures. 

    Finally, Indonesia must improve its testing capacity. The country has one of the lowest testing rates in the world at 444 tests per 1 million people, compared with 12,488 in South Korea and 2,727 in Taiwan. Although Jokowi has repeatedly called for more testing, it remains to be seen whether or not Indonesia can boost its capacity. Widespread testing would provide reliable data to inform decision-making and enable the government to identify infection hotspots. 

    For Indonesia, a total lockdown could indeed have cataclysmic social and economic consequences. The country surely needs an alternative approach. Open and transparent communication with the public, combined with widespread testing and the use of advanced technology similar to what South Korea and Taiwan have demonstrated, can help Indonesia manage the pandemic.

    The views expressed in this article are the author’s own and do not necessarily reflect Fair Observer’s editorial policy.

  • How Indonesia Lost the Battle Against the Coronavirus

    Indonesia coronavirus

    Image courtesy of Marketwatch

    Indonesian President Joko “Jokowi” Widodo’s response to the pandemic or lack thereof has sparked criticisms within and beyond Indonesia. The hashtag #lockdownordie is currently trending in Indonesia’s social media as Jokowi continues to resist experts’ advice to implement a nationwide lockdown. As of April 28, The Indonesian government has reported more than 9,100 cases and 765 deaths. But a recent Reuters review suggested that more than 2,200 people in Indonesia have died from the coronavirus. According to researchers at the University of Indonesia, there could be 15 million cases and 140,000 COVID-19 related deaths by the end of May. So how did Southeast Asia’s largest economy mishandle the pandemic? 

    At the heart of the problem is the government’s delayed response to the pandemic. WHO Governor-general Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus confirmed the first coronavirus case outside of mainland China on January 20. However, it took the government nearly three months since the announcement to finally take serious containment measures. 

    Despite early warnings from public health experts, the government continued to deny and downplay the risks. In February, the country’s health minister Terawan Agus Putranto dismissed a study by Harvard researchers that suggested Indonesia may have underreported the outbreak. Putranto also claimed that Indonesians are immune to the virus due to their prayers. Similarly, Jokowi had publicly endorsed a traditional Indonesian herb drink as an antidote to the virus. Meanwhile, the country’s vice president Amin Ma’ruf suggested that drinking wild-horse milk can ward-off the virus. These unscientific claims are misleading and dangerous as they can prevent the people from taking physical distancing or proper hygiene measures. 

    Jokowi was initially more interested in protecting the economy than protecting the people from the virus. When other countries started to impose travel restrictions, the government offered foreign and domestic travelers up to 30% discount on airline and hotel fees to save the country’s tourism industry. The government also allocated $5.2 million to pay social media influencers to promote Indonesia to foreign travelers. 

    Moreover, the government has received criticisms for its failure to conduct widespread testing. Despite the recent effort to increase the country’s COVID-19 testing capacity, Indonesia’s testing rate is still one of the lowest in the world, with 264 tests per one million people. Meanwhile, Malaysia and Thailand have testing rates of 4,063 and 2,043 per one million people, respectively. According to a senior member of Indonesia’s COVID-19 taskforce, nearly 20,000 suspected coronavirus carriers in the country have not been tested. 

    Lack of transparency is another key issue with Indonesia’s COVID-19 response. On April 5, the National Disaster Mitigation Agency (BNPB) spokesman Agus Wibowo said that the number of COVID-19 cases that the central government’s reported did not match the numbers reported by the provincial governments. It was later revealed that the government told Depok Mayor Mohamad Idris to hide information about the first two COVID-19 cases in the country. In addition to underreporting the number of cases, the government also did not provide the public with accurate information on infection hotspots. Jokowi eventually admitted that he withheld some information to prevent the public from panicking. But lack of transparency can intensify public confusion and the spread of misinformation. 

    Additionally, there has been poor coordination between the central government and the provincial governments, which created more confusion among the public and government officials. Jokowi’s inconsistent statements regarding the authority of provincial governments to impose local lockdowns have created conflicting policies at the central and provincial levels. 

    The government’s mishandling of the crisis is not only undermining the government’s credibility in fighting the outbreak, but also putting the people at serious health risks. The continued rise in COVID-19 infections is now putting enormous pressure on the country’s already fragile health care system. Indonesia only has 12 hospital beds and 4 doctors per thousand people. As a comparison, South Korea has 115 hospital beds and 24 doctors per thousand people. 

    With its limited financial and health care resources, Indonesia should respond to this current health crisis proactively and strategically. While there has been a series of setbacks, it is not too late for the government to fix its mistakes and turn the tide around. But the Indonesian government must show leadership and design policies based on scientific evidence. Additionally, the central government must ensure transparency and proper coordination with other levels of government. 

  • Why Canada Should Help Developing Countries Fighting to Flatten the Curve

    Originally published on the Hamilton Spectator

    nigeria_bombers_women_4

    The spread of COVID-19 in developing countries will have catastrophic global consequences. Ottawa’s current $50-million commitment to help developing countries deal with the pandemic is a step in the right direction. However, Canada must do more to assist developing countries to contain the spread of the virus.

    To date, advanced economies such as the United States, Italy and France have been suffering the most from the virus. In Canada, more than 11,000 cases have been reported along with 153 deaths. However, the next wave of the outbreak is expected to hit developing countries and the impact will likely devastate their fragile economies and weak health care systems.

    The International Monetary Fund (IMF) has stated its commitment to mobilize $1 trillion to help countries that are struggling with the economic impact of the coronavirus. The IMF and the World Bank are also working together on emergency programs to help member countries, particularly developing countries and emerging markets.

    However, the current aid that has been made available for developing countries will not be sufficient. Since the outbreak began, more than $83 billion worth of capital had fled the emerging markets. According to the IMF chief Kristalina Georgieva, developing countries need at least $2.5 trillion in financial assistance to cope with the pandemic. The United Nations Secretary-General Antonio Guterres has also asked world leaders to provide developing countries with $2 trillion to help them fight the outbreak.

    Unlike advanced economies such as Canada, developing countries do not have the wherewithal to contain the virus. Even without the outbreak, many low-income countries relied on foreign aid to survive. Guterres argued that “there are dramatic humanitarian needs for these people even without this pandemic. But now, with COVID-19, we need to do everything possible to prevent the disease from coming to these areas.”

    In sub-Saharan Africa, there is only about one doctor per 5,000 people, compared to one for every 300 in Europe. The region is also lacking basic medical tools such as ventilators, beds, and masks. In Mali, for example, there is only roughly one ventilator per one-million people.

    Moreover, 41 percent of sub-Saharan Africa’s population is living in poverty. According to the Brookings Institute, the pandemic could reduce sub-Saharan Africa’s GDP by 2.1 percent. In a region where sustained economic growth is desperately needed to lift people out of abject poverty, the economic impact of the coronavirus will create serious economic and social problems.

    The outbreak and its economic impact can also fuel political violence in the region. In 2019, political violence in sub-Saharan Africa killed over 2,000 people and displaced thousands more. In places like Kenya and South Africa, COVID-19 containment measures have already turned violent as police used excessive force to enforce lockdowns and curfews.

    In the Middle East where some countries are still fighting wars, COVID-19 will escalate sectarian tensions and regional instability. For example, officials in Bahrain have accused Iran of “biological aggression.” The region’s youth unemployment rate is currently one of the highest in the world at 26.1 percent. Measures to contain the virus will likely increase this number and lead to civil unrest.

    Many other countries in Asia and Latin America are also facing similar risks.

    To date, the government of Canada has only earmarked $50 million to help poor countries deal with coronavirus. Some even suggested that now is not that time for Canada to use its resources to help people in other countries. In his tweet, Conservative leadership candidate Erin O-Toole said: “Foreign aid can wait. Right now, the Trudeau government should prioritize Canadians.”

    But ensuring a stable international order is in Canada’s national interests. A major outbreak in developing countries can lead to global security issues such as terrorism, state violence, and refugee crises. All these problems will be detrimental to Canada’s national security.

    Currently, Canada only spends about 0.28 percent of its GDP on international development assistance (ODA). Meanwhile, other OECD countries such as Norway and Ireland spend at least 0.7 percent of their GDPs on ODA. Norway has also pledged $30 million to help developing countries fight the coronavirus, despite having a GDP of a mere $402 billion. With a GDP of more than $1.6 trillion, Canada should spend at least $150 million.

    The current pandemic requires Canada to step up and demonstrate its global leadership. Providing other countries with the financial resources to contain the spread of the virus will help protect Canadians now and in the future.

    Luthfi Dhofier is a policy analyst based in Vancouver. He recently graduated from UBC’s Master of Public Policy and Global Affairs program.

  • Poor Access to Clean Water Will Make Developing Countries Vulnerable to Coronavirus

    World Water Day was recently celebrated to highlight the importance of clean water. Almost all human activities require water, including food production, energy generation, and health provision. Globally, 800 million people, mostly in developing countries, do not have access to clean water. Lack of clean water contributes to a myriad of health problems such as diarrhea cholera, and dysentery. Every year, 3.4 million people, mostly children, die from water-related diseases. Water is also crucial in the current fight against COVID-19, as frequent handwashing can significantly reduce the spread of the virus. This means those 800 million people who have no access to clean water are highly vulnerable to the illness. The current COVID-19 pandemic is a sobering reminder that clean water is a critical requirement for human health.

    At the time of this writing, the virus has infected more than 330,000 people in 173 countries and killed 14,000. On March 11, the World Health Organization declared COVID-19 a global pandemic. With the exception of a few countries such as Taiwan and South Korea, governments around the world are struggling to contain the spread of the virus. Italy now has more deaths than China, while the United States and other European countries continue to see spikes in cases and deaths.

    In many developing countries, containing the spread of COVID-19 will be extremely challenging as they are already dealing with ongoing economic issues and weak healthcare systems.

    handwashing.jpg

    COVID-19 went undetected in many developing countries for a few months. Pakistan confirmed its first case as late as February 26, while Indonesia’s first case was only reported in early March. Yet, Southeast Asia now has more than 3,200 cases and in Africa, more than 1,100 cases have been confirmed. The numbers will only continue to rise. Governments in Egypt, Peru, and Nigeria have all imposed travel restrictions and banned public gatherings in their efforts to contain the virus.

    However, preventing the spread of COVID-19 also requires proper hygiene, which includes frequent handwashing for 20 seconds. While this may seem like a simple hygiene practice, there are millions of people who cannot wash their hands as they do not have access to clean water.

    According to UNICEF, forty percent of people around the world do not have access to handwashing facilities and soap in their homes. Fifty percent of schools in developing countries do not have handwashing facilities.

    In Africa, 258 million people do not have access to handwashing facilities. Many people who live in Africa and Asia must walk for more than 10 kilometers to obtain water from distant sources and the water is often contaminated with various harmful pathogens. Moreover, women mostly bear the responsibility to collect water, which deprives them of education and employment and exposes them to violence. For these people, frequent handwashing does not make too much sense as they already lack water for drinking purposes.

    Healthcare facilities in developing countries lack access to clean water, increasing healthcare workers’ exposure to the virus as they are not able to wash their hands as frequently as they should. A study by WHO found that 1 in 5 healthcare facilities around the world does not have adequate basic water services. This situation will likely exacerbate the spread of COVID-19 in these countries.

    The current COVID-19 pandemic shows that diseases can easily move from one country to another and become a global crisis. In this interconnected world, the lack of universal access to clean water can exacerbate global health risks. Therefore, improving global access to clean water must be a concerted effort by all countries.

    The United Nations Sustainable Development Goal (SDG) 6 provides a framework to ensure sustainable management of water and sanitation for all. However, the world is not on track to meet this goal and the amount of funding that goes into this effort must significantly increase. Rich countries can do more to help developing countries improve their water infrastructures and management.